Is $250,000 a good price for a home in New York Mills?

According to BuyPulse, 53745 440th Street rates Fair Market Value — at $203/sqft it's priced right at the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft. Powered by the Realgorithm™.

What type of heating and cooling does 53745 440th Street have?

53745 440th Street has Forced Air heating and Central Air cooling.

Where is 53745 440th Street located?

53745 440th Street is in New York Mills, MN 56567, in Otter Tail County.

Is 53745 440th Street still available?

Yes — 53745 440th Street is currently listed as Active on the MLS and accepting showings. Contact us to schedule a tour or make an offer.

When was 53745 440th Street built?

53745 440th Street was built in 2001. It features a block foundation.

Does 53745 440th Street have main-floor laundry?

Yes — the laundry at 53745 440th Street is on the main level.

How walkable is 53745 440th Street?

53745 440th Street has a Walk Score of 0/100 (Car-Dependent) and a Bike Score of 26/100 (Minimal Bike Infrastructure).

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 1 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 2 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 3 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 4 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 5 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 6 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 7 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 8 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 9 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 10 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 11 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 12 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 13 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 14 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 15 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 16 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 17 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 18 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 19 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 20 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 21 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 22 of 23)

2001 single family home for sale at 53745 440th Street in New York Mills, MN — 3 bed, 2 bath (photo 23 of 23)

53745 440th Street, New York Mills, MN 56567

3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,232 Sq Ft | Single Family Home | MLS# 7151035

$250,000

Is 53745 440th Street a Good Deal?

BuyPulse Verdict

Fair Market Value

At $203/sqft — This home is priced right at the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft.

$1,522/month Estimated

Principal & interest: $1,264
Property taxes: $112
Home insurance (est.): $146
HOA dues: None

20% down ($50,000) · 30-yr fixed, 6.5% · Can I afford this home?

Estimates only; confirm before you offer.

New York Mills, MN Active

About This Home

Rural New York Mills: This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home is set on a beautiful 3.45 acre wooded lot. The 2001 home has a 26x27 attached garage and a 30x40 pole building with lean-to. Recent updates include newer forced air furnace with central A/C, Shingles, and water softener. Located just off County Hwy 67, 7 miles North of New York Mills or 12 miles from Perham. To enjoy even more space, the adjoining 5 acre lot that is currently in CRP is available to purchase.

Key Features

Built: 2001
Garage: 2-Car Attached
Style: One
HOA: None
Annual Taxes: $1,348 (2026)

Property Details

Property Type: Single Family
Above Grade Sq Ft: 1,232
Lot Size: 3.45 acres
Basement: No
Roof: Age 8 Years or Less, Asphalt
County: Otter Tail
List Date: 2026-09-25
Days on Market: 17 days
Parcel ID: 33000080045004

Financial

Total Tax incl. Assessments: $1,348

Home Systems & Utilities

Heating: Forced Air
Cooling: Central Air
Water: Sand Point
Sewer: Septic System Compliant - Yes, Tank with Drainage Field
Appliances: Dishwasher, Electric Water Heater, Fuel Tank - Rented, Range, Refrigerator, Water Softener Owned

Interior Features

Laundry: Main Level

Construction & Exterior

Construction & Structure

Foundation Type: Block
Foundation Area: 1,232 sqft
Total Building Area: 1,232 sqft

Exterior Features

Exterior Features: Vinyl
Other Structures: Pole Building
Accessibility Features: None

Parking & Garage

Parking Features: Attached Garage, Gravel, Garage Door Opener

Lot & Land

Zoning Description: Residential-Single Family

Agent & Office

List Office: Coldwell Banker Preferred Part

Price History

Listed at $250,000 on Sep 25, 2026 — No price changes

53745 440th Street is listed in New York Mills, MN, part of Otter Tail County. Browse all Minnesota homes for sale on Modern Market REALTORS®.

Showing — 53745 440th Street

Shannon Barnum

Associate Broker · Modern Market REALTORS®

Your New York Mills real estate expert since 2012 — I represent you, not the seller. Quick to respond, easy to text.

See all New York Mills homes ›

Listed by Coldwell Banker Preferred Part · Shown by Modern Market REALTORS®

Schedule a Home Tour

First-Time Home Buyer Guide for Fargo-Moorhead — ND/MN buyer programs, budgeting, and the 7-step process.

View Full Listing & Photos

MLS# 7151035 · Data refreshed September 28, 2026

Similar Homes for Sale Near 53745 440th Street, New York Mills, MN

See all homes for sale in New York Mills, MN →

Frequently Asked Questions About 53745 440th Street

Is $250,000 a good price for a home in New York Mills?: According to BuyPulse, 53745 440th Street rates Fair Market Value — at $203/sqft it's priced right at the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft. Powered by the Realgorithm™. Browse New York Mills homes for sale to compare.
What type of heating and cooling does 53745 440th Street have?: 53745 440th Street has Forced Air heating and Central Air cooling.
Where is 53745 440th Street located?: 53745 440th Street is in New York Mills, MN 56567, in Otter Tail County.
Is 53745 440th Street still available?: Yes — 53745 440th Street is currently listed as Active on the MLS and accepting showings. Contact us to schedule a tour or make an offer.
When was 53745 440th Street built?: 53745 440th Street was built in 2001. It features a block foundation.
Does 53745 440th Street have main-floor laundry?: Yes — the laundry at 53745 440th Street is on the main level.
How walkable is 53745 440th Street?: 53745 440th Street has a Walk Score of 0/100 (Car-Dependent) and a Bike Score of 26/100 (Minimal Bike Infrastructure). Scores provided by Walk Score® →

Local Companies to Help You Settle In

From inspection to closing to moving day, here are well-known local companies serving the New York Mills area.

Listings courtesy of NorthstarMLS as distributed by MLS GRID

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 10/13/2026, 1:17 AM CDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.