42911 County Highway 53, New York Mills, MN 56567
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 800 Sq Ft | Single Family Home | MLS# 7132208
Is 42911 County Highway 53 a Good Deal?
BuyPulse Verdict
Premium Pricing
At $686/sqft — This home is priced 238% above the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft.
Powered by the Realgorithm™ — 10 active New York Mills listings · NorthstarMLS
$3,218/month Estimated
- Principal & interest
- $2,776
- Property taxes
- $122
- Home insurance (est.)
- $320
- HOA dues
- None
20% down ($109,800) · 30-yr fixed, 6.5% · Can I afford this home?
Estimates only; confirm before you offer.
Located in Jackson & Mckees Add, New York Mills, MN.
About This Home
Level 117' of pristine shoreline on Big Pine Lake with stunning sunset views and a sandy-bottom waterfront. This completely remodeled true craftsman cabin blends rustic charm with modern comfort, quiet and efficient spray-foam insulation. Enjoy in-floor heat, mini-split cooling, and beautiful polished concrete floors, all just steps from the water. The large lot offers plenty of room to expand, including the opportunity to add a garage. Easy year-round access makes this the perfect lake home in every season. Big Pine Lake spans approximately 4,775 acres and is known scenic boating, and outstanding fishing. A rare opportunity to own a beautifully updated lakeside cabin where rustic character meets quality modern construction.
BuyPulse™ — Live Market Read
Homes like this one — single-family homes between $412K and $686K in New York Mills:
- The field: 4 similar New York Mills homes for sale — a short list right now.
Powered by the Realgorithm™ — real New York Mills closings, zero guesses · NorthstarMLS
Key Features
- Built
- 1950
- Style
- One
- HOA
- None
- Annual Taxes
- $1,464 (2026)
Property Details
- Property Type
- Single Family
- Above Grade Sq Ft
- 800
- Lot Size
- 0.33 acres
- Basement
- No
- Roof
- Age 8 Years or Less, Asphalt
- Construction
- Concrete, Frame
- County
- Otter Tail
- List Date
- 2026-08-24
- Days on Market
- 49 days
- Parcel ID
- 52000990328000
Financial
- Total Tax incl. Assessments
- $1,464
Home Systems & Utilities
- Heating
- In-Floor Heating
- Cooling
- Ductless Mini-Split
- Electric
- 100 Amp Service
- Water
- Private, Shared System
- Sewer
- Holding Tank
- Appliances
- Tankless Water Heater
Construction & Exterior
Construction & Structure
- Foundation Type
- Poured Concrete
- Foundation Area
- 800 sqft
- Total Building Area
- 800 sqft
Exterior Features
- Exterior Features
- Cedar
- View
- North, West
- Accessibility Features
- None
Parking & Garage
- Parking Features
- None
Lot & Land
- Lot Features
- Tree Coverage - Medium
- Road Surface
- County Road, Paved Streets
- Zoning Description
- Shoreline,Residential-Single Family
Waterfront
- Waterfront
- Yes
Agent & Office
- List Office
- New Horizons Realty Of Perham
Price History
Listed at $549,000 on Aug 24, 2026 — No price changes
42911 County Highway 53 is listed in New York Mills, MN, part of Otter Tail County. Browse all Minnesota homes for sale on Modern Market REALTORS®.
Showing — 42911 County Highway 53
Associate Broker · Modern Market REALTORS®
Your New York Mills real estate expert since 2012 — I represent you, not the seller. Quick to respond, easy to text.
See all New York Mills homes ›
Listed by New Horizons Realty Of Perham · Shown by Modern Market REALTORS®
Buying a home in New York Mills? — dedicated buyer representation from pre-approval through closing.
View Full Listing & PhotosMLS# 7132208 · Data refreshed August 27, 2026
Similar Homes for Sale Near 42911 County Highway 53, New York Mills, MN
Frequently Asked Questions About 42911 County Highway 53
- Is $549,000 a good price for a home in New York Mills?
- According to BuyPulse, 42911 County Highway 53 rates Premium Pricing — at $686/sqft it's priced 238% above the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft. Powered by the Realgorithm™. Browse New York Mills homes for sale to compare.
- What type of heating and cooling does 42911 County Highway 53 have?
- 42911 County Highway 53 has In-Floor Heating and Ductless Mini-Split cooling.
- Where is 42911 County Highway 53 located?
- 42911 County Highway 53 is in the Jackson & Mckees neighborhood of New York Mills, MN 56567, in Otter Tail County.
- Is 42911 County Highway 53 still available?
- Yes — 42911 County Highway 53 is currently listed as Active on the MLS and accepting showings. Contact us to schedule a tour or make an offer.
- When was 42911 County Highway 53 built?
- 42911 County Highway 53 was built in 1950. It features concrete, frame construction and a poured concrete foundation.
- How walkable is 42911 County Highway 53?
- 42911 County Highway 53 has a Walk Score of 0/100 (Car-Dependent). Scores provided by Walk Score® →
- How many homes like 42911 County Highway 53 are for sale in New York Mills?
- 4 similar homes (single-family homes between $412K and $686K in New York Mills) are for sale right now — a short list right now.
- What does "BuyPulse" mean?
- BuyPulse™ is Modern Market REALTORS®’ live market-data brand for Fargo-Moorhead: cohort statistics — homes for sale, median days to pending, and share of sales closing at or over list price — computed from real NorthstarMLS closings, not estimates.
- What does "Realgorithm™" mean?
- The Realgorithm™ is Modern Market REALTORS®’ proprietary market-data engine — it computes every BuyPulse verdict from real NorthstarMLS closings (comparable active inventory, median days to pending, and sale-to-list price ratio) rather than an automated online estimate.
Local Companies to Help You Settle In
From inspection to closing to moving day, here are well-known local companies serving the New York Mills area.
Listings courtesy of NorthstarMLS as distributed by MLS GRID
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 10/13/2026, 1:17 AM CDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.