42911 County Highway 53, New York Mills, MN 56567
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 800 Sq Ft | Single Family Home | MLS# 7132208
Is 42911 County Highway 53 a Good Deal?
BuyPulse Verdict
Premium Pricing
At $686/sqft — This home is priced 238% above the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft.
Powered by the Realgorithm™ — 13 active New York Mills listings · NorthstarMLS
$3,218/month Estimated
- Principal & interest
- $2,776
- Property taxes
- $122
- Home insurance (est.)
- $320
- HOA dues
- None
20% down ($109,800) · 30-yr fixed, 6.5% · Can I afford this home?
Estimates only; confirm before you offer.
Deciding Week · Day 6 of 7
Day count from the MLS listing date · cohort stats from the last 90 days · NorthstarMLS
Located in Jackson & Mckees Add, New York Mills, MN.
About This Home
Level 117' of pristine shoreline on Big Pine Lake with stunning sunset views and a sandy-bottom waterfront. This completely remodeled true craftsman cabin blends rustic charm with modern comfort, quiet and efficient spray-foam insulation. Enjoy in-floor heat, mini-split cooling, and beautiful polished concrete floors, all just steps from the water. The large lot offers plenty of room to expand, including the opportunity to add a garage. Easy year-round access makes this the perfect lake home in every season. Big Pine Lake spans approximately 4,775 acres and is known scenic boating, and outstanding fishing. A rare opportunity to own a beautifully updated lakeside cabin where rustic character meets quality modern construction.
BuyPulse™ — Live Market Read
Homes like this one — single-family homes between $412K and $686K in New York Mills:
- The field: 4 similar New York Mills homes for sale — a short list right now.
Powered by the Realgorithm™ — real New York Mills closings, zero guesses · NorthstarMLS
Key Features
- Property Type
- Single Family
- Year Built
- 1950
- Above Grade
- 800 sq ft
- Lot Size
- 0.33 acres
- Lot Features
- Tree Coverage - Medium
- Heating
- In-Floor Heating
- Cooling
- Ductless Mini-Split
- Appliances
- Tankless Water Heater
- Sewer
- Holding Tank
- Water
- Private, Shared System
- Annual Taxes
- $1,464
- County
- Otter Tail
- Days on Market
- 4
42911 County Highway 53 is listed in New York Mills, MN, part of Otter Tail County. Browse all Minnesota homes for sale on Modern Market REALTORS®.
Showing — 42911 County Highway 53
Shannon Barnum
Associate Broker · Modern Market REALTORS®
Your New York Mills real estate expert since 2012 — I represent you, not the seller. Quick to respond, easy to text.
See all New York Mills homes ›
Listed by New Horizons Realty Of Perham · Shown by Modern Market REALTORS®
Buying a home in New York Mills? — dedicated buyer representation from pre-approval through closing.
View Full Listing & PhotosMLS# 7132208 · Data refreshed August 27, 2026
Similar Homes for Sale Near 42911 County Highway 53, New York Mills, MN
Frequently Asked Questions About 42911 County Highway 53
- Is $549,000 a good price for a home in New York Mills?
- According to BuyPulse, 42911 County Highway 53 rates Premium Pricing — at $686/sqft it's priced 238% above the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft. Powered by the Realgorithm™. Browse New York Mills homes for sale to compare.
- What type of heating and cooling does 42911 County Highway 53 have?
- 42911 County Highway 53 has In-Floor Heating and Ductless Mini-Split cooling.
- Where is 42911 County Highway 53 located?
- 42911 County Highway 53 is in the Jackson & Mckees neighborhood of New York Mills, MN 56567, in Otter Tail County.
- Is 42911 County Highway 53 still available?
- Yes — 42911 County Highway 53 is currently listed as Active on the MLS and accepting showings. Contact us to schedule a tour or make an offer.
- When was 42911 County Highway 53 built?
- 42911 County Highway 53 was built in 1950. It features concrete, frame construction and a poured concrete foundation.
- How walkable is 42911 County Highway 53?
- 42911 County Highway 53 has a Walk Score of 0/100 (Car-Dependent). Scores provided by Walk Score® →
- How many homes like 42911 County Highway 53 are for sale in New York Mills?
- 4 similar homes (single-family homes between $412K and $686K in New York Mills) are for sale right now — a short list right now.
- What does "BuyPulse" mean?
- BuyPulse is Modern Market REALTORS®’ live market-data brand for Fargo-Moorhead: cohort statistics — homes for sale, median days to pending, and share of sales closing at or over list price — computed from real NorthstarMLS closings, not estimates.
- What does "Realgorithm™" mean?
- The Realgorithm™ is Modern Market REALTORS®’ proprietary market-data engine — it computes every BuyPulse verdict from real NorthstarMLS closings (comparable active inventory, median days to pending, and sale-to-list price ratio) rather than an automated online estimate.
Local Companies to Help You Settle In
From inspection to closing to moving day, here are well-known local companies serving the New York Mills area.