Is $484,900 a good price for a home in New York Mills?

According to BuyPulse, 51692 385th Street rates Premium Pricing — at $255/sqft it's priced 26% above the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft. Powered by the Realgorithm™.

What type of heating and cooling does 51692 385th Street have?

51692 385th Street has Forced Air, In-Floor Heating and Central Air cooling.

Where is 51692 385th Street located?

51692 385th Street is in New York Mills, MN 56567, in Otter Tail County.

Is 51692 385th Street still available?

Yes — 51692 385th Street is currently listed as Active on the MLS and accepting showings. Contact us to schedule a tour or make an offer.

When was 51692 385th Street built?

51692 385th Street was built in 2009. It features frame construction, a metal roof, and a slab foundation.

Does 51692 385th Street have main-floor laundry?

Yes — the laundry at 51692 385th Street is on the main level.

How walkable is 51692 385th Street?

51692 385th Street has a Walk Score of 0/100 (Car-Dependent) and a Bike Score of 15/100 (Minimal Bike Infrastructure).

How many homes like 51692 385th Street are for sale in New York Mills?

5 similar homes (single-family homes between $364K and $606K in New York Mills) are for sale right now — a short list right now.

What does "BuyPulse" mean?

BuyPulse is Modern Market REALTORS®’ live market-data brand for Fargo-Moorhead: cohort statistics — homes for sale, median days to pending, and share of sales closing at or over list price — computed from real NorthstarMLS closings, not estimates.

What does "Realgorithm™" mean?

The Realgorithm™ is Modern Market REALTORS®’ proprietary market-data engine — it computes every BuyPulse verdict from real NorthstarMLS closings (comparable active inventory, median days to pending, and sale-to-list price ratio) rather than an automated online estimate.

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 1 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 2 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 3 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 4 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 5 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 6 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 7 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 8 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 9 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 10 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 11 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 12 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 13 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 14 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 15 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 16 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 17 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 18 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 19 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 20 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 21 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 22 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 23 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 24 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 25 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 26 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 27 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 28 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 29 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 30 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 31 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 32 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 33 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 34 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 35 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 36 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 37 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 38 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 39 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 40 of 41)

2009 single family home for sale at 51692 385th Street in New York Mills, MN — 2 bed, 2 bath (photo 41 of 41)

51692 385th Street, New York Mills, MN 56567

2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,900 Sq Ft | Single Family Home | MLS# 7055422

$484,900

Is 51692 385th Street a Good Deal?

BuyPulse Verdict

Premium Pricing

At $255/sqft — This home is priced 26% above the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft.

$2,848/month Estimated

Principal & interest: $2,452
Property taxes: $113
Home insurance (est.): $283
HOA dues: None

20% down ($96,980) · 30-yr fixed, 6.5% · Can I afford this home?

Estimates only; confirm before you offer.

New York Mills, MN Active

About This Home

Located in rural New York Mills and just minutes from Perham! Discover your dream home, one level living, nestled on 10 acres along a serene country road. This exceptional property boasts 2+ bedrooms, including a primary suite and 2 bathrooms. Features a heated 4 stall attached garage and a workshop area—perfect for hobbies or projects. Step inside to find the open floor plan highlighted by large windows, flooding the space with natural light. 9-foot ceilings and a stunning gas fireplace! The kitchen offers oak cabinetry, stainless steel appliances and a large walk-in pantry. The spacious primary suite is a true retreat, offering a luxurious walk-in closet and an oversized bathroom with a double sink. Start your mornings off with a cup of coffee under the inviting covered front porch. The expansive acreage is ideal for a hobby farm and offers a 30x30 horse barn with a hydrant already in place. The backyard overlooks an absolutely stunning creek bottom with an abundance of deer & turkey! This maintenance free exterior, turn-key home is ready for you to make it your own—don’t miss out on this incredible opportunity!

Virtual Tour

Take a virtual tour of this home

BuyPulse™ — Live Market Read

Homes like this one — single-family homes between $364K and $606K in New York Mills:

The field: 5 similar New York Mills homes for sale — a short list right now.

Key Features

Property Type: Single Family
Year Built: 2009
Above Grade: 1,900 sq ft
Lot Size: 10.00 acres
Lot Features: Suitable for Horses, Tree Coverage - Medium
Garage: 4-car (Attached Garage, Gravel, Finished Garage, Garage Door Opener, Heated Garage, Storage)
Heating: Forced Air, In-Floor Heating
Cooling: Central Air
Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Fuel Tank - Rented, Humidifier, Gas Water Heater, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliances, Washer
Sewer: Private Sewer, Septic System Compliant - Yes, Tank with Drainage Field
Water: Private, Well
Annual Taxes: $1,356
County: Otter Tail
Days on Market: 137

51692 385th Street is listed in New York Mills, MN, part of Otter Tail County. Browse all Minnesota homes for sale on Modern Market REALTORS®.

Showing — 51692 385th Street

Shannon Barnum

Associate Broker · Modern Market REALTORS®

Your New York Mills real estate expert since 2012 — I represent you, not the seller. Quick to respond, easy to text.

See all New York Mills homes ›

Listed by Trilogy Real Estate · Shown by Modern Market REALTORS®

Schedule a Home Tour

Buying a home in New York Mills? — dedicated buyer representation from pre-approval through closing.

View Full Listing & Photos

MLS# 7055422 · Data refreshed August 25, 2026

Similar Homes for Sale Near 51692 385th Street, New York Mills, MN

See all homes for sale in New York Mills, MN →

Frequently Asked Questions About 51692 385th Street

Is $484,900 a good price for a home in New York Mills?: According to BuyPulse, 51692 385th Street rates Premium Pricing — at $255/sqft it's priced 26% above the typical New York Mills single-family home of $203/sqft. Powered by the Realgorithm™. Browse New York Mills homes for sale to compare.
What type of heating and cooling does 51692 385th Street have?: 51692 385th Street has Forced Air, In-Floor Heating and Central Air cooling.
Where is 51692 385th Street located?: 51692 385th Street is in New York Mills, MN 56567, in Otter Tail County.
Is 51692 385th Street still available?: Yes — 51692 385th Street is currently listed as Active on the MLS and accepting showings. Contact us to schedule a tour or make an offer.
When was 51692 385th Street built?: 51692 385th Street was built in 2009. It features frame construction, a metal roof, and a slab foundation.
Does 51692 385th Street have main-floor laundry?: Yes — the laundry at 51692 385th Street is on the main level.
How walkable is 51692 385th Street?: 51692 385th Street has a Walk Score of 0/100 (Car-Dependent) and a Bike Score of 15/100 (Minimal Bike Infrastructure). Scores provided by Walk Score® →
How many homes like 51692 385th Street are for sale in New York Mills?: 5 similar homes (single-family homes between $364K and $606K in New York Mills) are for sale right now — a short list right now.
What does "BuyPulse" mean?: BuyPulse is Modern Market REALTORS®’ live market-data brand for Fargo-Moorhead: cohort statistics — homes for sale, median days to pending, and share of sales closing at or over list price — computed from real NorthstarMLS closings, not estimates.
What does "Realgorithm™" mean?: The Realgorithm™ is Modern Market REALTORS®’ proprietary market-data engine — it computes every BuyPulse verdict from real NorthstarMLS closings (comparable active inventory, median days to pending, and sale-to-list price ratio) rather than an automated online estimate.

Local Companies to Help You Settle In

From inspection to closing to moving day, here are well-known local companies serving the New York Mills area.